Causes of Longitudinal Cracks in Cast Billets
You are here: Home » Blogs » Causes of Longitudinal Cracks in Cast Billets

Causes of Longitudinal Cracks in Cast Billets

Views: 0     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2026-08-17      Origin: Site

Inquire

wechat sharing button
line sharing button
twitter sharing button
facebook sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
sharethis sharing button

Surface defects in continuous casting directly impact mill profitability and operational efficiency. Untreated surface defects inevitably lead to downstream rolling failures, material scrap, and severe production bottlenecks. When operators encounter billet longitudinal cracks, they face a severe process control failure rather than a simple metallurgical anomaly. These defects compromise yield rates, increase energy waste, and force costly manual conditioning of cast products. Resolving these surface fractures requires a systematic evaluation of thermo-mechanical stresses, chemical composition limits, and cooling infrastructure. Plant managers must determine the correct process interventions and equipment upgrades to stabilize production. You will learn how to diagnose the root causes of these cracks, optimize mold flux performance, and implement advanced traceability systems to ensure long-term structural integrity in your continuous casting operations.

  • Uneven or excessive mold cooling and high superheat are the primary drivers of thermal stress, leading to thin shell formation and subsequent hot tearing.
  • Chemical composition—specifically high sulfur, phosphorus, and nitride precipitates (Al, B, Nb)—drastically increases crack susceptibility at elevated temperatures.
  • Selecting the right mold flux and optimizing lubrication is critical to maintaining uniform heat transfer and minimizing friction-induced stress.
  • Investing in online traceability, automated defect detection systems, and optimized mold geometries provides the necessary data to balance casting speed with structural integrity, ensuring long-term yield stability.

The Mechanics of Billet Longitudinal Cracks

Defining the Defect

Accurate defect identification on the shop floor requires a clear understanding of physical characteristics. Longitudinal cracks run parallel to the casting direction. They vary significantly in length, sometimes spanning just a few millimeters, while severe cases extend for several meters along the billet surface. Depth is equally variable. Micro-cracks may only penetrate one to two millimeters into the surface, but major fractures can breach the solidification zone, exposing the liquid core and risking a catastrophic breakout. Identifying the exact location of the fracture provides the first diagnostic clue regarding the underlying process failure. Operators must map whether the crack sits dead center on the face, off-center, or runs tightly along the corner radius.

To standardize defect identification on the casting floor, operators should follow a strict inspection sequence:

  1. Clean the billet surface thoroughly using wire brushes or high-pressure water descaling to remove loose scale.
  2. Visually inspect the face and corner radii under high-intensity lighting immediately after the straightener.
  3. Measure the crack length and depth using a calibrated depth gauge or portable ultrasonic testing equipment.
  4. Log the defect location relative to the specific mold faces to isolate potential cooling zone failures.

Differentiating Crack Topographies

Distinguishing between longitudinal facial cracks and longitudinal corner cracks is essential for targeted troubleshooting. Corner defects in square billets almost always point to mechanical failures within the mold assembly. Improper corner radius design fails to accommodate the natural shrinkage of the solidifying steel. Mold taper degradation also triggers corner cracking. As the copper tube wears down over hundreds of heats, it loses its engineered taper, failing to support the shrinking shell. Facial cracks lean heavily toward thermal irregularities. They indicate cooling water flow issues, uneven mold flux infiltration, or localized hot spots where the shell lost contact with the copper mold.

Crack Topography Diagnostic Guide

Defect Type Primary Location Common Mechanical Causes Common Thermal/Chemical Causes
Facial Cracks Center or off-center of the billet face Mold tube distortion, uneven wear profiles Irregular flux melting, uneven primary cooling, high superheat
Corner Cracks Directly on or adjacent to the corner radius Loss of mold taper, incorrect corner radius geometry Over-cooling at the corners, severe air gap formation

Thermo-Mechanical Behavior and Hot Tearing

The physics of shell formation in the continuous casting mold dictate the likelihood of defect generation. As molten steel contacts the water-cooled copper mold, a thin solid shell forms instantly at the meniscus. This initial shell is fragile and subjected to intense thermo-mechanical stresses. Ferrostatic pressure from the liquid core pushes outward, while thermal contraction pulls the solidifying metal inward. When the localized tensile stress exceeds the high-temperature yield strength of the solidifying shell, hot tearing occurs. This tearing initiates just below the meniscus, where the shell is thinnest and most vulnerable to friction and thermal shock. If the shell does not gain sufficient thickness before exiting the mold, the secondary cooling sprays will exacerbate these micro-tears into massive longitudinal fractures.

Impact on Downstream Processing

Allowing micro-cracks to pass through the caster to the rolling mill carries severe consequences. During the rolling process, these longitudinal defects do not weld shut. Instead, the mechanical pressure of the rolling stands forces the cracks to open further, propagating deep into the finished rebar, wire rod, or structural shape. This results in heavy scaling, surface seams, laps, and ultimate product rejection. Strict quality thresholds must be enforced at the caster discharge. Immediate process correction prevents the compounding waste of energy and time spent rolling inherently defective material. Scrapping a billet at the caster is always more efficient than scrapping finished rolled products.

Primary Metallurgical and Chemical Causes

High Sulfur (S) and Phosphorus (P) Content

Elevated levels of sulfur and phosphorus fundamentally weaken the structural integrity of the steel matrix at high temperatures. During solidification, these elements segregate heavily at the austenite grain boundaries. Sulfur reacts with iron to form iron sulfide (FeS). This compound has a significantly lower melting point than the surrounding steel matrix. Consequently, liquid FeS films persist along the grain boundaries even as the bulk of the steel solidifies. These liquid films drastically reduce the hot ductility of the shell. When thermal stress is applied during primary cooling, the shell simply pulls apart along these weakened boundaries, initiating billet longitudinal cracks.

Evaluating the operational limits of secondary metallurgy refining is a necessary step. Pushing sulfur and phosphorus limits down requires longer treatment times in the ladle furnace and higher consumption of desulfurizing agents. Maintaining sulfur levels strictly below 0.015% for crack-sensitive grades ensures the solidifying shell retains enough ductility to survive the mold. Operators often utilize manganese additions to maintain a high Manganese-to-Sulfur (Mn/S) ratio, typically above 20. This forces the sulfur to form manganese sulfide (MnS) instead of FeS, which precipitates as isolated globular inclusions rather than continuous liquid films along the grain boundaries.

Nitride Embrittlement (Aluminum, Boron, Niobium)

Micro-alloying elements like aluminum, boron, and niobium are necessary for achieving specific mechanical properties in the final steel product. They introduce significant risks during the continuous casting process. As the steel cools through specific temperature ranges, typically between 700°C and 950°C, these elements react with nitrogen to form nitride precipitates such as AlN, BN, and NbN. These precipitates form heavily along the austenite grain boundaries.

The precipitation of nitrides pins the grain boundaries in place, severely restricting plastic deformation. This phenomenon creates a pronounced ductility trough. If the billet undergoes severe thermal gradients or mechanical stress—such as in the unbending zone of a curved caster—the embrittled grain boundaries fracture. Metallurgists must control nitrogen levels aggressively during steelmaking and optimize secondary cooling curves to bypass the critical temperature ranges where precipitation is most rapid.

Effective mitigation strategies for nitride embrittlement include:

  • Limiting atmospheric nitrogen pickup during ladle transfer and tundish operations through strict argon shrouding.
  • Optimizing titanium additions to bind free nitrogen into stable titanium nitrides (TiN) before aluminum or niobium can react.
  • Adjusting secondary cooling spray patterns to keep the billet surface temperature above 950°C or below 700°C during the unbending phase.
Operational causes of billet longitudinal cracks in continuous casting

Operational and Process-Induced Root Causes

Uneven and Excessive Mold Cooling

Primary cooling within the mold dictates the initial formation of the steel shell. Irregular cooling water flow creates asymmetrical heat extraction. Scaled mold tubes, where calcium or magnesium deposits build up on the water side of the copper, act as thermal insulators. A scale layer just 0.5mm thick can reduce heat transfer by over 20%. Improper water jacket design can also lead to uneven water velocity across the mold faces. When heat extraction is asymmetrical, the shell grows unevenly. Thin spots lack the mechanical strength to withstand ferrostatic pressure, leading to localized bulging and longitudinal tearing.

The dangers of excessive primary cooling are equally severe. Over-cooling the mold drastically increases the temperature differential between the inner liquid-solid interface and the outer surface of the billet shell. This massive thermal gradient generates excessive tensile stress on the surface. The outer layer contracts rapidly while the inner layer remains expanded, literally ripping the shell apart. Mold wear and improper taper exacerbate this issue. A loss of taper creates an air gap between the copper tube and the shrinking shell. Air is a poor conductor of heat. This gap leads to localized hot spots, delayed solidification, and subsequent tearing. Evaluating mold water quality and enforcing strict cooling system maintenance schedules are non-negotiable practices.

High Superheat and Casting Speed Trade-offs

Molten steel superheat—the temperature of the steel above its liquidus point—directly controls the rate of early shell growth. High superheat delivers excessive thermal energy to the meniscus. This delays initial solidification, resulting in a thinner, weaker shell exiting the mold. A thin shell is highly susceptible to both bulging and longitudinal cracking under the stress of secondary cooling sprays. Target superheat ranges should generally be maintained between 20°C and 30°C above the liquidus temperature for optimal shell formation.

The compounding effect of high casting speeds pushes this risk further. Faster casting speeds reduce the mold residence time. The steel spends less time in contact with the primary cooling zone, yielding an even thinner shell at the mold exit. Operators must utilize a strict decision matrix for optimizing casting speed against tundish temperature controls. If superheat spikes due to ladle sequencing delays, casting speed must be proportionally reduced to allow sufficient shell thickness to develop before the billet enters the secondary cooling zone.

Mold Slag/Flux Performance and Lubrication Failures

Mold powder serves multiple functions: it protects the meniscus from oxidation, absorbs non-metallic inclusions, provides uniform lubrication, and regulates heat transfer between the solidifying shell and the copper mold. Inappropriate slag viscosity is a primary driver of surface defects. If the viscosity is too high at operating temperatures, the liquid slag cannot infiltrate the gap between the shell and the mold evenly. This leads to localized friction, causing the shell to stick to the copper and tear.

Poor melting rates or uneven slag film thickness lead to erratic thermal variations. A crystalline slag film extracts heat differently than a glassy slag film. If the flux fails to maintain a consistent state, heat transfer becomes chaotic, inducing massive thermal stresses across the billet face. The selection of mold flux requires precise alignment with specific steel grades, casting speeds, and oscillation parameters to prevent friction-induced stress.

Mold Flux Property Comparison

Flux Property Impact on Low-Speed Casting Impact on High-Speed Casting
Viscosity Higher viscosity acceptable; prevents excessive slag consumption. Lower viscosity required; ensures rapid infiltration into the mold gap.
Melting Rate Slower melting rate maintains a stable powder pool. Fast melting rate necessary to replenish liquid slag consumed by high speeds.
Crystallization Temp Higher crystallization temperature reduces heat transfer, preventing over-cooling. Lower crystallization temperature maintains liquid lubrication over a longer distance.

Evaluating Process Control Solutions and Upgrades

Upgrading Mold Cooling Infrastructure and Geometry

Relying on outdated mold geometries guarantees a high defect rate. Assessing the return on investment for replacing standard copper mold tubes with advanced geometries is a priority. Parabolic tapers and multi-taper designs are engineered to match the exact shrinkage profile of the solidifying steel as it cools from the meniscus down to the mold exit. Optimized corner radii for square billets prevent the shell from pulling away from the corners prematurely. Maintaining continuous contact between the copper and the shrinking billet prevents air gaps and ensures uniform heat extraction.

Implementing closed-loop water cooling systems provides another layer of defense. These systems utilize real-time flow and temperature monitoring on every individual water circuit. By tracking the exact temperature delta of the cooling water entering and exiting the mold, operators can instantly detect asymmetrical heat extraction.

Steps to implement a closed-loop water monitoring system:

  1. Install high-precision electromagnetic flow meters on all individual mold water inlet circuits.
  2. Integrate RTD temperature sensors on both the inlet and outlet headers to measure the exact thermal delta.
  3. Connect sensor outputs to a centralized PLC for real-time heat flux calculation across all mold faces.
  4. Establish automated alarm thresholds for flow deviations or temperature spikes exceeding baseline parameters.

Optimizing Chemical Composition and Tundish Temperature

Temperature control must begin long before the steel reaches the mold. The integration of automated temperature control systems in the tundish is essential for maintaining a consistent, low superheat. Plasma heating or induction heating systems within the tundish allow operators to hold the steel temperature within a tight 5°C to 10°C window above the target. This consistency eliminates the thermal shocks that cause erratic shell formation and prevents the sudden superheat spikes associated with fresh ladle openings.

Investment in advanced ladle metallurgy stations tightens control over chemical composition. Deep desulfurization and precise calcium treatment modify inclusions and reduce the formation of low-melting-point films. Vacuum degassing can be employed to strip nitrogen from the melt, directly mitigating the risk of nitride embrittlement. Tighter chemical controls at the ladle stage drastically reduce the metallurgical variables that cause cracking in the caster, ensuring the steel arrives at the tundish in an optimal state for continuous casting.

Implementing Online Traceability and Defect Detection

Modern continuous casting requires data-driven quality control. Optical and thermal imaging systems are now capable of real-time surface inspection of hot billets immediately after the straightener. High-speed cameras and pyrometers scan the surface for temperature anomalies and physical fissures. These systems flag defects long before the billet cools, preventing defective material from being transferred to the rolling mill and allowing operators to quarantine bad heats immediately.

Integrating machine learning and traceability software elevates this capability. By correlating specific surface defects with exact casting parameters recorded at the time of formation—such as casting speed, tundish temperature, mold oscillation frequency, and cooling rates—the software performs rapid root-cause analysis. This allows metallurgists to pinpoint the exact variable that drifted out of tolerance, enabling immediate corrective action for subsequent heats rather than waiting for manual inspection reports the following day.

Implementation Risks and ROI Trade-offs

Balancing Production Output with Quality Controls

Operational friction frequently arises between production managers and metallurgists. Production teams are incentivized to maximize throughput, pushing for higher casting speeds to clear the melt shop. Metallurgists require slower speeds to ensure thicker shell formation and defect-free surfaces. Addressing this friction requires a clear financial framework. Calculating the true cost of a scrapped billet—including the wasted raw materials, energy, alloy additions, and lost production time—often reveals that the marginal gain of increased casting speed is negated by a minor increase in defect rates. Speed must always be subordinate to stable shell formation.

Cost of Consumables vs. Yield Improvement

Procurement departments often target mold powder as a cost-saving category. Evaluating the financial impact of switching to premium, grade-specific mold fluxes reveals a different reality. Cheap mold powders frequently suffer from inconsistent melting behaviors, poor viscosity control, and high moisture content. The hidden costs of cheap mold powders include increased maintenance downtime to clean breakouts, higher defect rates requiring manual scarfing, and accelerated wear on the copper mold tubes. Investing in high-quality flux tailored to the exact casting conditions yields a massive return through uninterrupted production and zero-defect billets.

System Integration Challenges for Monitoring Tools

Installing online defect detection in the harsh, high-temperature environment of a continuous caster presents significant technical hurdles. Sensors, cameras, and cabling are exposed to radiant heat, steam, flying scale, and occasional molten metal splashes. Hardware degradation can lead to false positives or complete system failures if not properly managed.

Mitigation strategies are essential for successful adoption. Phased rollouts allow the maintenance team to adapt to the new technology without overwhelming their daily schedules. Robust sensor shielding, utilizing water-cooled housings and air-purged lenses, protects delicate optics from the casting environment. Comprehensive operator training ensures that shop-floor personnel understand how to interpret the traceability software data and take appropriate action, rather than ignoring automated alarms when they trigger.

Conclusion

  • Conduct a comprehensive audit of current breakout rates, superheat averages, and mold water quality to establish a strict performance baseline.
  • Inspect all copper mold tubes for taper degradation and scale buildup, replacing any units that fall outside engineered dimensional tolerances.
  • Evaluate your current mold flux specifications against your primary steel grades to ensure optimal viscosity and heat transfer rates.
  • Implement automated temperature control systems in the tundish to maintain a strict superheat window and stabilize initial shell formation.
  • Deploy online thermal imaging and traceability software to correlate surface defects with real-time casting parameters for immediate root-cause analysis.

FAQ

Q: What is the primary cause of billet longitudinal cracks in continuous casting?

A: The primary causes are high thermal stress and friction in the mold. These are driven by uneven or excessive mold cooling, high steel superheat, improper mold flux lubrication, and high levels of sulfur or phosphorus that weaken the solidifying shell.

Q: How do excessive and uneven mold cooling contribute to surface defects in steel billets?

A: Excessive cooling creates a massive temperature differential between the surface and the core, generating tensile stress that rips the shell. Uneven cooling causes localized thin spots in the shell, which cannot withstand internal ferrostatic pressure and tear open.

Q: Why do longitudinal corner cracks appear more frequently in square billets?

A: Corner cracks in square billets are typically mechanical failures. They occur when the mold loses its engineered taper due to wear, or when the corner radius design fails to accommodate the natural shrinkage of the steel, causing the shell to pull apart at the corners.

Q: What role does superheat play in the formation of longitudinal cracks?

A: High superheat delays the initial solidification of the steel at the meniscus. This results in a thinner, weaker shell exiting the mold. A thin shell is highly vulnerable to bulging and tearing under the stress of secondary cooling.

Q: How do sulfur and phosphorus levels affect the hot ductility of cast billets?

A: Sulfur and phosphorus segregate at the grain boundaries during solidification. Sulfur forms iron sulfide (FeS) films, which have a low melting point. These liquid films remain at high temperatures, drastically reducing hot ductility and causing the steel to fracture under stress.

Q: Can changing mold flux prevent longitudinal cracking?

A: Yes. Mold flux provides essential lubrication and regulates heat transfer. Switching to a flux with optimized viscosity and melting rates prevents the shell from sticking to the mold and ensures uniform heat extraction, drastically reducing friction-induced cracking.

INFO

Tel: +86-510-85215215
Email: sales@wuxiliwei.com
          liweiyejin@163.com
Add: 912-915, 52#, Jingxian Road, Xinwu District, Wuxi, Jiangsu, China

QUICK LINKS

PRODUCT CATEGORY

CONTACT US

Contact Us
Copyright © 2024 WUXI LIWEI METALLURGY EQUIPMENT CO., LTD. All Rights Reserved.| Sitemap